One Child Left Behind: A 4yr history of my child in the public school system that failed him. PDF Print E-mail
Written by OHmommy   
Wednesday, 06 February 2013 00:00

The thing I dislike most about myself is that instead of celebrating something, I wonder what I could've done differently.

 

This is highlighted most in my ongoing struggle to give my first born child all the resources possible for him to succeed in school. And while I danced around this afternoon celebrating his latest proclamation "I feel like I'm doing a gazillion times better at my new school" - (he had the written proof too! - high written remarks from his teachers because no reports cards until 8th grade in our new progressive school) secretly on the inside all I could think of was that my maternal instincts were right all along, and I should have acted on them sooner to save my son from struggling for years.

 

photojaydesk

 

Years! He never truly belonged in his old school (a traditional school in an outstanding Ohio district where I watched my daughter thrive). I knew by kindergarten that things in school were "off" for him and me. He is in fourth grade now. Fourth!

 

I've written over and over again, throughout these blogging years, that "The biggest mistake I made in my parenting career is that I allowed an award-winning public school district to lead me" and "I feel like my public school system has left my child behind and dragged him along" and even early on that "If I was able to rewind, I would've told his kindergarten teacher that I was (more) concerned". But what better did I know? I was repeatedly reassured at meetings that the school was on my side, doing the best they could. For four elementary school years I regurgitated those words to my husband, "They are doing the best they can with what they've got!" hoping that the more I said it out loud, the more convinced I would be.

 

I knew he didn't belong in a traditional school setting.

 

"We are thinking about private schools for Jay." I said at one of the last IEP meetings in Ohio, knowing very well that it was nothing we could really afford but if I had to take out a job pumping gas 24/7 on the corner to afford tuition, I would. "No, no. We can modify things and add resources." I was told by the team. And while it worked for a month or two (Look... I celebrated!) what I didn't document online was the slow decline afterwards. No one ever took my statement "I feel like my child is left behind" seriously enough, in my opinion. I still lose sleep over the fact that they didn't take the words "I wish you were dead" directed towards my son seriously enough, in my opinion. I think the school was lacking in resources for someone like my child, like so many schools across the country are.

 

Just re-reading through years of posts that I linked to about our struggles sends me into a rage of tears. How blind was I? Why didn't I trust my instincts? When did I begin to trust administration more than myself?

 

"I feel like I'm doing a gazillion times better at my new school." Jay smiled. Without getting into too many details he is getting fifteen hours of resources a week in his new school compared to the fifteen hours a month at our old school. That doesn't even include the before-school resource hours - that's an extra three hours a week, bringing the new total up to eighteen hours a week. Just. To. Catch. Up. Because it was apparent to our new school just how much he was left behind (that statement made me weep). He is no longer sitting in-front of a computer program trying to improve his comprehension but sitting next to an actual teacher who incorporates what is taught in class. We are lucky. We are at a school that actually developed the idea of the resource room. The resource room concept started right here in our Chicago school!

 

"We will not leave your child behind." Our new public school reassured me at our IEP meeting. "We will go above and beyond to do what is needed."

 

I hope our new school is a good fit because I've grown to question the public school system. For years I trusted and was constantly discouraged by administration. Not anymore. My child will not be left behind.

 

Last Updated on Wednesday, 06 February 2013 09:45
 

Comments  

 
# Elizabeth 2013-02-06 01:22
I both love this and am saddened by it. I have read all of your posts and commented on them all in the past. My daughter was left behind in Kinder and I knew it too. The school and we at home tried so many different things that lasted for a month or two and then she fell behind again. Ultimately, she just belongs in a non-traditional school setting. For various reasons, we can't switch her until high school. She has 3 years left. We'll get through and we have settled into more of a groove but I wish that I had listened to my gut the whole time. I'm glad that you guys were able to push the re-start button!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# alexandra 2013-02-06 02:59
Welcome to the Mother Club, where the hardest person to forgive is ourself.

I am still chastising myself for allowing the school convince me to leave my then 10yr old boy in a traditional setting.
He is now 16, and thriving, but only after I pulled him out.

But for so long, for at least three years, my poor son, how my poor son cried. HE KNEW he didn't belong there more than anyone else--and no one listened.

I am still angry with myself.

At least, I finally learned to believe my gut over the teachers. BUT WHY DID I LISTEN TO THE TEACHERS FOR FAR TOO LONG???
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Suburbia Interrupted 2013-02-06 07:38
As a mother of a 9yo with a reading/processing LD,
I know your struggles, heartbreak, anger and second guessing. I have been in a battle with our school district to get my son and others with LDs the education they deserve. Like you, we are in an area that has the best schools in our county, which have been wonderful for my four other children who have thrived in school. The district has failed the one who needs the most help.

I am so glad your son is doing better. I read a quote last week about LDs and loved it: "People with learning disabilities have small islands of weakness scattered among their sea of strength." Keep being an excellent mother and your child's biggest advocate and supporter!!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Shannon 2013-02-06 09:30
I am so happy for you and your son (and daughters, too) that you found a school that fits. As a parent and former teacher, I really believe that most schools and teachers are trying really hard to do what is best for the masses. But that's just it, right? THE MASSES.
I hope you won't be too hard on yourself. He's only in fourth grade. That's a lot earilier than many students and parents find the right school match, if they ever do. He still has the majority of his schooling in front of him. More importantly, he has a mother who is willing to fight for his wellbeing behind him. And my guess is that he knows it.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Chefs Widow 2013-02-06 09:36
I know you're struggles with this have been far from easy but I also wanted you to know that your story with Jay inspired and cemented our move last year with C-Money. The best thing we have ever did school wise with our son came from you. You are as always an inspiration to me and I can't wait to see you in May!!! xoxo
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Chefs Widow 2013-02-06 09:37
I meant YOUR not you're.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Lisa 2013-02-06 10:08
Amazing story! I have been reading along with your struggles over the years. I'm glad you found such a great school. Hopefully it proves to be everything your children need it to be, and a great place for them to succeed!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Amy 2013-02-06 10:31
I am reading this and nodding my head with you. I just returned from with the school guidance counselor and my 3rd grader's teacher about how she is doing and what we can do to make her want to go to school. Part of it is social, a girl bullying her and the other is the ADD aspect of approaching learning.
I cried with you as your documented the journey of Jay's learning and I am so happy for your family that the light at the end of the tunnel is burning bright for him.
To have a child who went from angst of school to thriving is inspiring and hopeful to me. Thank you for being the inspiration you are.
Hugs and love
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Tracey 2013-02-06 10:47
Not all children fit into the same pegs. My square peg did NOT fit into their round hole, and I wasn't willing to try and chip away at his corners any more. But we waited until fourth grade, too. It seems to be at that age that we realize that they are who they are and it is NOT just normal stuff that all kids grow out of. No two kids learn the same way, and it makes me angry to think of all of the schools that convince parents to just keep on plugging away in the same path as before, even if it hasn't been working.

I am glad Jay is loving his new school so much more. I wish all kids had access to progressive and non-traditional schools...
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Shannon 2013-02-06 15:23
I don't usually comment, but I could have written this post about my firstborn daughter. I came to dread conference times with her teachers because I knew I was working so hard at home doing all that was recommended and just. not. getting. far.

I wanted to encourage you, though, and say (from hindsight) that somewhere along the way I had an epiphany of sorts and realized that God is far more concerned with my daughter's character than her report card.

I had always focused on the things we needed to improve and overlooked the teacher's comments about her shining character.

She's in high school now, and we no longer live in Ohio, but she is doing well academically (though it doesn't come easy). To this day however, she has a particular heart for volunteering and service and helping others- something her teachers have been telling us since preschool. And I would much rather see that than straight A's honestly.

I guess what I'm saying is, with all your love and attention, your son is going to succeed at what matters most (in my opinion) which is his character. He is very blessed to have such an involved mother!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Beth Cleary 2013-02-06 15:47
mother Knows best...
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# YoMamaMorris 2013-02-06 20:36
Hindsight is 20/20--don't beat yourself up over it! At least you did act. We mothers are so hard on ourselves, replaying memories constantly, wondering what we could have done differently when in fact, we're actually doing a pretty good job! If you asked your son to grade you, I'm sure you'd get straight As. :)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Sandra 2013-02-06 20:50
I love all of your posts but I do not normally comment. This story struck home with me tonight and tears are rolling down my face as I write this. I too should have listened to my heart back in the days when my son was in pre-school. Heck he was thrown out of one because "he didn't fit in" with the other what I would call Stepford children to be kind. There was just something and I could not put my finger on what. I had already had 2 other children whom had severe disabilities (they have since passed away), so I knew something wasn't right. But... this child was bright and smart. AND...something was NOT right. Leaving him in public school was the worst thing I have done to my child. He was bullied unmercifully and he too was not a fighter. He came home depressed with tears many days. I finally got an answer from a Dr.-he has OCD. I pulled him from public school and now I sell on eBay so that I can pay for private school. My son is treated so much better in a school that teaches respect and so much more. With time & much work, he is developing into a wonderful young man. I am glad I finally "listened" to my heart and fought for an answer to what was wrong, I just wish it hadn't taken me so long. I hope that all moms whom read this and suspect for one moment something is wrong, will in fact follow their hearts too.
Thank you for opening up to the public on a private situation. It is people like you whom will help people like me and others and it's appreciated.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Cynthia 2013-02-06 21:37
We too have a gifted daughter who suffered through public school with very serious and difficult medical conditions. As an elementary school teacher myself, I had hoped that I could make the case for our daughter and encourage the flexibility necessary to accommodate a smart student who simply was unable to be present in class as frequently as the school would like. She was accused of "faking" illness, although one would think that documentation of stays in intensive care units would have been effective in stopping that. Finally, as a senior, a newly developed independent study program with an intelligent and empathetic young teacher, mended some of the damage done and allowed her to graduate with her class. But when I think of the hurt inflicted on our child by ignorant teachers and principals, I am full of rage to this day and most of this anger is directed at myself for not listening to and acting on what my heart knew was right to do. Indeed, it is true that mother knows best!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Marta 2013-02-07 17:55
I am so happy that Jay is getting all the support that he deserves and needs. You can't focus on what he didn't get, and who was right and who was wrong (SO much easier said than done I know), but just keep reminding yourself that he's doing good NOW. He's getting the support he needs NOW. And I'm so delighted that you found a school that is a great fit for him.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Melanie 2013-02-14 13:50
I just received phone calls from my son's teachers and letters sent home about their promotion being in doubt. My oldest has struggled from the beginning, I too have ignored my own instincts about him and public school. He is in the process of being evaluated for a LD, pertaining to processing and retaining material. His brother started having issues this year in 3rd grade, according to predictive testing for the state tests.
Here in NY, if you do bad during the school year, but pass the state tests that start in the third grade, you can go through to the next grade. If you fail the state tests but do well during the year, you can pass as well. You can also go to summer school and take the tests again to see if you pass, if you have failed them during the regular school year.
My children are in one of the best school districts in NYC and my 11 year old gets resource room for math and language arts a few times a week. A major problem is that the state tests are not really based on the grade appropriate material they are learning in class, rather the tests are a grade or two ahead. So, the teachers have to stop their "regular learning" every January to focus on the state testing material and getting these kids to at least pass the tests. Does this make any sense?
All of the children mentioned in the post and comments are bright, intelligent children and as parents we have pulled out all the stops to help them, yet we have all been left behind.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Michelle 2013-02-14 19:04
I am SO happy for you - and more importantly, for him! It's so hard when you have a child who doesn't fit into the round holes they've created for each child. My square peg did great at a private school for two years, last year wasn't good. We moved him, and this school... it's amazing. I'm so glad you're getting what you need because it makes all the difference in the world. But you CANNOT beat yourself up. They're the supposed experts, and you should be able to trust them. The fact that you can't... sucks.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
# Elaine A. 2013-02-18 17:54
Wow, it sounds like things are going much better for him in your new place and that is wonderful! Try not to feel guilty or bad about that past. I know it's hard, I have my own hurdles like that to cross... xo
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Random Posts

Why I dumped Carson Kressley for Wade Rouse
Last summer, I was in a "relationship" w...
I can't make this stuff up. #worstmomoftheyear
Yesterday, I lost touch with the last re...
You won't find me in the diaper aisle anymore...
She might still occasionally drink her m...
A Blogging Thanksgiving
Recently, Neil and Jennifer (whom I've b...
I'm Speaking at BlogHer '12 I'm Speaking at BlogHer '09
I'm speaking

Author

Pauline Karwowski.

Is a self proclaimed globe trotting, minivan driving, SAHM stiletto ho.

Happily married mother to 3 Cleveland natives: Jay the son, Lola the daughter, and Fifi the banshee.

Now in Chicago, IL.

The content on this blog is the opinion of the blogger.

ClassyC_button_Mother

Email Subscription

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

CrocStyle Insider